Neighborhood Services Director Jonathan Burch stands at the podium with the Oak Park village board sitting behind the village hall desk.
Neighborhood Services Director Jonathan Burch presents information on short-term rentals in Oak Park at the village board meeting on Nov. 17, 2026. Credit: Sydney Lovan

On Halloween, a woman was fatally shot in a domestic dispute after leaving a house party in Oak Park. The party took place at a short-term rental property at 1028 S. Humphrey Ave., driving neighbors and community members to share concerns on regulations to the village board.  

The village board heard, and shared their own similar concerns, at a meeting on Nov. 17, and gave general direction for village staff to draft an updated, stricter ordinance on short-term rentals.Ā Ā 

ā€œI think we need to be tough as nails to make sure everybody understands that Oak Park is not just a party place to come and throw your party,ā€ Trustee Jim Taglia said at the meeting.  

Neighborhood Services Director Jonathan Burch presented information shared by Village Manager Kevin Jackson in a memo which outlines current license standards and information and specific details on the S. Humphrey home.  

There are currently 144 active and delinquent licenses to operate short-term rentals, with 276 total applications and 124 canceled licenses since 2022, according to the memo. 

Each year, a license has to be renewed by paying a fee and scheduling an inspection. If neither or only one of those steps are completed by May 31, the deadline for renewal, and they are still operating, then they are considered delinquent.Ā Ā 

There are progressive fines of $200, then $500 and $750 for violations of the village code. There are also occupancy limits set by the number of rooms, with 13 people in a six-bedroom home being the largest.Ā Ā 

The village board proposed ideas for stronger restrictions such as minimum rental of two days, no parties over the occupancy limit, a no party tolerance if one is caught, increased fines, limiting the number of licenses approved, and working with the rental platforms like Airbnb to not allow advertising or booking until proof of a license is available.  

ā€œI believe that the safety of the community comes before the ability for folks to rent out a house for a night, especially for folks who don’t even live in the community,ā€ Trustee Cory Wesley said.  

The property owner in question has a delinquent license currently, and has been issued a ticket from the village. This is one of over 50 tickets issued for short-term rentals this year due to a new Housing Licensing Coordinator increasing the capacity for enforcement.  

There have been 12 calls for service about that property since 2023 with four calls about two separate parties in September and October 2024. There were no calls for a party at that home this year until Halloween.Ā Ā 

Licenses can be suspended or revoked, and the Village Manager has authority to immediately order the closure of a short-term rental if it is deemed a nuisance or ā€œa clear and present danger to the public health, safety or general welfare.ā€ 

ā€œI think we’ve reached that threshold,ā€ said Taglia about the S. Humphrey rental. ā€œI think this rental should be closed until such time as they can appear before the manager in a hearing, and then it can go to the next step, which may be suspension, revocation.ā€ 

All trustees and President Vicki Scaman shared support for a revised ordinance and many expressed similar interest in pursuing accountability for the individual property, which is still listed on Airbnb for rental.  

Trustee Chibuike Enyia shared his personal interest in that property as his daughter was at a sleepover on S. Humphrey when the shooting occurred, and his want to protect children from having violent incidences become normalized.  

Trustee Jenna Leving Jacobson emphasized that there needs to be an overarching public safety component to these conversations.  

ā€œThis is unfortunately a reminder that gun violence is a community problem that impacts neighborhoods when it happens, not just the individual, not just the family, and it’s just that much more of a reason that we should be holistic and comprehensive in our approach,ā€ Leving Jacobson said.  

Police Chief Shatonya Johnson shared her agreement with the board that the safety of the community is a top priority, and she is ā€œall forā€ whatever they can do to strengthen it. Increased police presence has already been implemented for that area of Oak Park following the October incident.  

ā€œI’m committed to this community. Your police officers are committed. We want to do everything we can to keep folks safe. We also want to make sure that we’re operating constitutionally,ā€ Johnson said.  

Trustee Derek Eder approached the conversation from a different perspective with the increasing issue of housing availability and affordability, and how short-term rentals ā€œare contributing to a reduction in the number of units.ā€Ā 

ā€œI think I want to take a more proactive and maybe preventative approach,ā€ Eder said.  

The owner and operator of the other short-term rental on the same block of S. Humphrey, Dwayne Smith, spoke at the meeting recognizing the harm that has been caused, but also urging the board to not penalize all owners who follow the rules.  

ā€œI even complained about this Airbnb, and I am joined with my neighbors in the stigma and the problems that Airbnb caused or is causing,ā€ Smith said. ā€œI will say that I also caution boards: be careful, we want to be proactive, but we don’t want to attack the owners and the business people who maintain and manage quality Airbnbs.ā€ 

With the direction and opinions given by the village board, village staff can work to draft an updated ordinance and present it at a future meeting for an official vote. At this time, no official changes have been made to the code.  

Join the discussion on social media!