Federal Judge Matthew Kennelly said Thursday that he will make a ruling soon on former Oak Parker Tommy Schaefer’s motion to dismiss the most serious criminal charge pending against him.
At a hearing on Nov. 19, Kennelly said he’d have a ruling “in about two weeks,” and scheduled a Dec. 10 hearing on the matter.
On Sept. 18, defense attorney Michael Baker filed a motion to dismiss Count 2 which charges Schaefer with Conspiracy to Commit Foreign Murder of United States National. Baker argued, among other things, that the government failed to demonstrate that it obtained approval of the U.S. Attorney General to prosecute Schaefer for the foreign murder of Oak Parker Sheila von Wiese Mack, as required under Section 1119 of the U.S. Criminal Code.
Section 1119 bars the prosecution of a defendant in the United States where the defendant was previously prosecuted by a foreign country.
Schaefer has already admitted during his 2015 trial in Indonesia that he viciously beat Weise Mack to death with the metal stand from a fruit bowl. He served 11 years of an 18-year sentence in a Bali prison before being released this past February and deported to the United States.
The defense’s argument hinges on whether this section of U.S. Code applies to Schaefer’s case, and not Section 1117, as the prosecution insists. Section 1119 requires the written approval of the U.S. Attorney General before indicting; Section 1117 does not.
In early October, the government responded, saying Schaefer “asks this court to do what it has already declined to do for his co-defendant Heather Mack: dismiss Count Two of the indictment based on an alleged failure by the government to satisfy an administrative requirement of a statute that was not charged.” Heather Mack is the daughter of Wiese Mack.
Schaefer, prosecutors argue, is charged with a conspiracy pursuant to 1117, which is a separate and distinct criminal offense that contains no requirement for Attorney General approval.
Schaefer “is not charged with the substantive offense (murder),” covered by Section 1119, prosecutors argued, “and is only charged with a conspiracy (to murder, covered under Section 1117).”
“Unlike the murder statute, the conspiracy statute does not by its plain language have any prior approval requirements for prosecution.”
Comments by Baker and Judge Kennelly suggest that the ruling is likely to have a major impact on how Schaefer’s prosecution will proceed. His trial is currently scheduled for March 15.
Baker told the judge that his upcoming ruling “will have an impact on the decision” regarding what Schaefer’s defense team will do next.
“I’m not expecting you to know what you’re going to do by then,” Kennelly told Baker. “But you’ll have more information.”
In May 2023 Kennelly ruled on a similar motion by Schaefer’s co-defendant Heather Mack. In that case he ruled that Section 1117 governed the terms of the indictment, making it “unnecessary for the court to delve further into the parties’ constitutional arguments.”
Eight weeks after Kennelly’s ruling, Mack entered a plea agreement and pleaded guilty. She was later sentenced to 26 years in prison.
On Thursday the judge also discussed Schaefer’s ongoing complaint that he is not being afforded adequate medical attention for a low blood oxygen condition likely related to long Covid or tuberculosis contracted while imprisoned on Bali.
Kennelly appeared a bit miffed at hearing that Schaefer had been taken to a hospital on three occasions without receiving treatment.
Following the hearing, he issued a written order directing Baker “to reach out to the attorney advisor at the MCC regarding the apparent repeated cancellations of Mr. Schaefer’s outside hospital appointments.”
Kennelly authorized Metropolitan Correctional Center officials “to turn over the medical records from Mr. Schaefer’s November medical visits (including his outside medical visits) to both government and defense counsel.” He set a telephonic status hearing for Nov. 25 to discuss Schaefer’s medical care and formally directed the attorney advisor at the MCC “to participate in the telephonic hearing.”
