Fall is in the air and the harvest is in. Our celebrated Farmers Market has sadly closed, but not before I got there, and now I’m looking at, and trying to decide what to do with, a very full bushel of assorted apples. Let’s see, pies and tarts for the Northern Spies, to be sure, and those Rome Beauties are always great for baking. The remainder of the bushel is all Honey Crisps, my favorite apple of all, I admit, and for those I have a somewhat different treatment.

A favorite way to eat apples is “out of hand,” of course, but it is the fall season and I can’t help but notice the ubiquitous “Affy Tapple,” the popular caramel apple on a stick that seems to be in just about every grocery store. Did you know that Affy Tapples were created in Chicago as far back as 1948? The company relocated to Niles in 2007 and continues to be a favorite fall treat.

Now Affy Tapples are great for the kids, but I prefer a more grown-up approach, if you will; one that’s a bit friendlier to your teeth and certainly friendlier to someone with a moustache like mine. I make my own caramel sauce, and instead of skewering the apple on a stick and dipping it in caramel, it’s far more enjoyable to simply cut the apple into wedges and dip them one by one as you go.

Caramel is nothing more than the mixture that’s produced when sugar has been cooked until it melts and becomes a thick, golden-to-deep-brown liquid. Water is often used to thin the syrup, which has myriad uses both in the sweet and savory kitchen. There are two ways to make caramel, either by the dry method, where the sugar is placed in a saucepan and is cooked to the desired color, or by the wet method where the sugar is dissolved in water before it’s cooked. There is less danger of burning the caramel with the wet method, but as a caution, once water has been added to the sugar, you must refrain from stirring it to prevent crystallization.

Here's my recipe:

1 cup sugar

1 tablespoon dark corn syrup

¼ cup water

½ cup whipping cream (heated)

1 tablespoon unsalted butter (room temperature)

1 teaspoon vanilla extract

  •  In a heavy-bottom saucepan, heat the sugar, corn syrup and water without stirring
  •  If it looks like the sugar is forming crystals on the side of the saucepan, gently shake the pan back and forth to dissolve the crystals
  •  Allow the syrup to cook over medium heat until it turns a reddish brown/amber color
  •  Remove the mixture from the heat and slowly add the whipping cream
  •  Stir the mixture with a wooden spoon until it is smooth and creamy
  •  Stir in the unsalted butter
  •  Allow the mixture to cool slightly and add the vanilla extract.

You can now cut your favorite apple into wedges and dip them into this wonderful, versatile sauce that can be used for other fruit or as a topping for ice cream.

Apples and caramel are a classic flavor combination. Enjoy the grown-up approach to caramel apples and enjoy the fall season!

Join the discussion on social media!

Frank Chlumsky, former executive chef of Philander's restaurant in Oak Park, teaches in Chicago at Kendall College's School of Culinary Arts. In his 37-year career, Frank has owned restaurants in Michigan...