Having served for 35 years as attorney for the Oak Park Plan Commission, I have a particular interest in the rezoning debate swirling through the village. Although retired and no longer practicing law, I have a suggested solution – forget rezoning. Instead, make all middle housing (2, 3, 4, 5 and 6-flats) a special use in all single-family districts.
Doing this will give everyone what they want: middle housing will be allowed in every single-family district — if it meets the special-use standards — including that the project is compatible with the neighborhood. The public will get notice and an opportunity to be heard before any middle-housing construction. Finally, the village will maintain control of the project.
Designating middle housing a “special use” portends no outcome; it simply allows the
village to ask whether a particular development works at a particular location. If it does, it gets approved. If it doesn’t, then the village can impose conditions and restrictions to
make it compatible with the neighborhood or if that’s not possible, the village can reject the project.
The trustees had it right when they changed course in July and changed proposed six-flats from a permitted use to a special use in single-family districts. They just didn’t take it far enough — all so-called “middle housing” in single-family districts should be a special use.
After all, allowing anywhere from two to six times the number of family units is a significant change in the intensity of use and requires individual consideration of the impact of these multi-family buildings upon the neighbors.
There are those who argue that the special-use procedure adds time and expense for middle-housing developers. To an extent that is true; it takes time to listen to people’s concerns. It takes time to review a development. It takes time to make sure that it’s compatible with the surrounding neighborhood. But that will take a lot less time than the time it will take to correct an issue after it’s been built.
Ultimately, this provides an incentive to developers to propose thoughtful developments, which will serve all our interests and ensure that the process takes the minimum time and expense.
The special-use procedure is a nuanced, pragmatic and common-sense approach to the introduction of middle housing into established single-family zones. It addresses residents’ concerns by giving all of us a voice in the process. This procedure allows middle-housing development, while avoiding unintended consequences, like McMansions, which can result from the village’s broad-brush rezoning approach currently before this commission.
No rezoning. Make middle housing a special use. It’s a win-win. Or as close as we’ll get to one.
Dick Martens is a longtime resident of the village and former attorney for the Oak Park Plan Commission.
