On Nov. 16, 1989, during El Salvador’s civil war, soldiers from the elite Atlacatl Battalion murdered six Jesuit priests, their housekeeper and her teenage daughter at the Central American University in San Salvador. 

I remembered that event when I heard about the death of legendary jurist and former Chief Judge of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit in Chicago, Richard Posner. 

In a funny way, Judge Posner’s legacy reminds me of the sorry state of the U.S. Justice Department today and its political (and failed) prosecution in cases such as our own local Broadview 6. 

In 2007, I was representing “John Doe,” an El Salvadoran solider who was present at these government-ordered murders. Doe later cooperated with a United Nations Truth Commission sent to investigate. 

With Doe’s firsthand account, the Truth Commission wrote a scathing report which led to the President of El Salvador resigning and most senior military brass being cashiered. 

The Jesuits helped Doe to flee El Salvador when the UN report was issued and to get to the U.S. because of threats on his life. Doe then filed for political asylum in Chicago, which he was denied in front of the Board of Immigration Appeals because he was a “persecutor.” 

If there ever was a risk of political persecution in an asylum case, this was it. Back in El Salvador, because he had blown the whistle, Doe would be a dead man. He would not make it out of the airport. 

That’s where I got involved, representing Doe in the appeal of his denial of political asylum to the Seventh Circuit. 

At oral argument before three appeals court judges, including Judge Posner, I laid out the case for political asylum. The U.S. Justice Department lawyer took the position that Doe was a persecutor and statutorily ineligible for asylum. 

That’s where Judge Posner became electric on the bench. I had clerked at the U.S. Court of Appeals some years earlier, and Posner was regarded as a brilliant innovator of law and economics, bringing a Milton Friedman-type eye into adjudication of the law. 

And he could be, how should I put it, “aggressive” in questioning lawyers. He came out of the University of Chicago, where intellectual arguments were a kind of blood sport. 

I got through my oral argument without much damage. Maybe I was saved by the fact that another panelist that day was Judge Ilana Rovner whom I had clerked for some years before. 

Then it was the Justice Department lawyer’s turn to argue. It didn’t take Posner long to pounce. I paraphrase: 

Posner: Why is Doe a persecutor who is ineligible for political asylum? 

Government lawyer: He was a soldier carrying a gun. 

Posner: Of course he carried a gun. He’s a soldier. 

Government Lawyer: But he was present at the murder … 

Posner: Of course he was. The evidence is that he was ordered to be present by his superiors but he didn’t shoot anyone. That makes him a persecutor? 

After drubbing the Government’s lawyer, Judge Posner turned to me and asked me if I had any further rebuttal. 

“Not at this time,” I said, keeping my butt in my chair and my big mouth shut. 

Classic Judge Posner. He had a strong dose of realism. He wouldn’t let a theory distract from the most material facts. 

We’re going to need more Richard Posners on the federal courts as we wash the stench of political prosecutions off our once vaunted U.S. Attorney’s Office in Chicago and Justice Department in Washington. See e.g. Prosecution of the Broadview 6. 

Join the discussion on social media!