After nearly 6 hours over two meetings and almost 80 speakers, public comment concluded for the plan commission hearing on the proposed changes to zoning in Oak Park.
Another 38 community members spoke at the Nov. 12 meeting in Village Hall with 30 speakers against the proposal, seven in favor and one who specifically labeled himself undecided. That brings the totals to 57 speakers in opposition and 21 supporting the changes.
From a homeowner whose home has been passed down for three generations to a renter who moved to Oak Park just this year and cannot afford to buy even as a dual-income household, people across ages, backgrounds, and housing types shared opinions and questions in their limited 3-minute stints at the podium.
Many who spoke against the proposal reiterated fears of the unknown on how zoning changes could impact living in Oak Park and cited issues including parking, traffic and neighborhood aesthetics, along with general concerns that the process has been moving too fast without enough information upfront.
Iris Sims, a former plan commission chair, kicked off the night with her opinion that the existing rules and processes do not need to be changed.
“We’re doing this backwards. There is no reason whatsoever, no reason whatsoever, that we cannot continue to use the existing plan process in an organic way, and continue to make changes to this village,” Sims said.
There were no boos or audience outbursts at this meeting. However, two speakers, Naomi Hildner and George Peterson, did receive standing ovations by a majority of the room.
Hildner shared her frustrations with village board members feeling that they did not run on “this extreme rezoning,” and if they had, they would not be elected. She called the proposed changes an “unproven whim.”
“Oak Park will be destroyed, and its charm and its character permanently lost,” Hildner said.
Peterson spoke to his personal experience as a Black man growing up in the 1960s and 70s being inspired by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., to act on his right to vote, and his disagreement with the denial of an advisory referendum on this subject.
“For me, it’s not about race, parking, infrastructure. I don’t care if it’s two, four, six units. I don’t care how close it is to the curb or to the alley. I don’t care about the height. It’s all about the right to vote period,” Peterson said.
On the other side, those who spoke in favor of the proposal shared fears that limited housing stock and rising prices will make it too difficult for middle-class families to move or keep living in the village without an increase in housing options.
“If we were house hunting today, we would not be able to afford our home. We have great jobs, and as a family, we’re about as diverse as you can get, and yet, families like mine are being priced out of our community,” said Oak Park resident Kelly Bencola.
Environmental impacts of housing were brought up once again as Laura Derks spoke on behalf of the Oak Park Climate Action Network and their support of a “revised zoning ordinance” that increases density to lower emissions intensity, sustains the electrification ordinance and encourages public transportation-oriented development.
She also listed three issues the organization wants to further be addressed in building codes or zoning: require high-quality green space be maintained, preserve existing structures instead of building new ones, and make sure new development would not shade existing residential solar panels.
The issue of school enrollment was brought up by both sides. Those against shared worries that too much density will make the schools overcrowded, and those in support shared worries of ongoing declines in enrollment rates which might eventually cause schools to close. Enrollment in public schools has been down across the country largely driven by lower birth rates.
A couple of new ideas from Simone Boutet, a former village trustee, seemed to draw interest from many in the room regardless of opinion on the exact zoning changes.
She suggested that instead of a pilot program based on location in the village, there could be a pilot program introducing just two flats across all neighborhoods. Additionally, she suggested that there be a requirement of one owner occupied unit, to try to restrict instances of absentee owners.
“I love my house. I’m not moving, but it does cost the environment. So I would like to see the opportunity for our existing houses to be divided into two units, and I also believe that the people who are most concerned about this, I think would probably be ok if there was a two flat next door,” Boutet said.
The plan commission process will continue with cross-examination on Dec. 2 at 6 p.m. back in Village Hall. The commissioners will then hold another meeting on Dec. 3 for deliberation and a possible vote on their recommendations to the village board. If a decision is not reached then, another meeting will be held on Dec. 9.
More information on the cross-examination rules, sign-up process and recordings of the previous meetings can be found on the village website.
