Recently, I asked a company to stop selling information about me. The company said no. Not because I failed to identify myself. Not because the information belonged to someone else, but because I live in Illinois.
A commercial data broker rejected my request to remove my personal information. Its explanation was that Illinois lacks a comprehensive consumer privacy law applicable to its data.
Think about that for a moment.
A private company can collect your home address, telephone numbers, age, previous residences, and family relationships, assemble them into a searchable profile, and make that information commercially available to strangers.
And when you ask them to stop, they can refuse. I find this deeply disturbing.
We lock our doors, safeguard our financial information, and take precautions against identity theft. Yet companies we have never done business with can compile detailed profiles of our personal lives and make them available to virtually anyone willing to pay.
We never meaningfully consented to this arrangement.
Worse, removing yourself from these websites is an exhausting exercise in digital whack-a-mole. There are hundreds of data brokers. Each maintains its own removal procedures. Some require email verification. Others demand additional personal information. Some remove your records only to have them reappear later.
And an entire industry now sells subscription services promising to help consumers remove information that another industry profits from distributing.
What a remarkable business model: monetize our personal information, then charge us to protect it.
This is not a partisan issue. Conservatives who value individual liberty and progressives who champion consumer protection should agree that Americans deserve meaningful control over their personal information.
California has enacted stronger consumer privacy protections. Illinois has not.
Why should someone in Oak Park have fewer privacy rights than someone in Pasadena?
Illinois legislators have considered comprehensive privacy legislation, including Senate Bill 2875, the Illinois Consumer Data Privacy Act, introduced in January 2026. But the legislation is stalled in committee, leaving meaningful protections unfinished.
Senate President Don Harmon, our own Oak Park neighbor, is uniquely positioned to help change that.
Illinois should establish a universal right to remove personal information from commercial data brokers, create a free centralized opt-out system, prohibit republication after removal, and impose meaningful penalties on companies that refuse to comply.
Congress should establish comparable protections nationwide.
We can preserve legitimate public records, journalism, and freedom of expression without allowing companies to commercially package and sell intimate details about ordinary Americans.
Our privacy should not be a commodity. Our personal safety should not depend on a corporation’s goodwill. And our fundamental rights should not depend on our ZIP code.
It’s time for Illinois to act.
David Hopp is an Oak Park resident.
