The U.S. Department of Justice continues to stiff arm attempts by Federal Judge April Perry to investigate alleged misconduct by prosecutors in the Broadview 6 case. 

Perry has said she intends to conduct a thorough inquiry into U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros’s claim that he was unaware of any problems related to his prosecutor’s handling of October 2025 grand jury proceedings. Boutros’s contentions have since been called into serious question. 

On Monday morning, Nov. 16 there was a 20-minute status hearing in Judge Perry’s courtroom, at which Associate U.S. Attorney Stanley Woodward appeared. Woodward recently took over representing the government in the case. 

The Sun-Times noted in a story Tuesday that Perry spent much of Monday’s status hearing “speaking with a new group of lawyers — representing the prosecutors who nearly took the ‘Broadview 6’ case to trial.” 

According to the paper, attorneys for William Hogan, Matthew Skiba and Andres Almendarez told Perry their clients do not plan to invoke the Fifth Amendment. 

But Woodward’s filings on Sunday made it clear he did not want any of the prosecutors to testify under oath, and that the release of any information requested by Perry should be at the sole discretion of the U.S. Attorney General and President Donald Trump.  

He also suggested the government intends to appeal.  

Woodward has previously asserted several types of legal privilege, including attorney work product. He also said he was not including any oral communications in response to Perry’s request, terming the request “impracticable.” 

At the very least, Woodward told the court Monday, it “should excuse any line prosecutors from having to testify. As to these matters, there is plainly no need for anyone but the U.S. Attorney to provide information.” 

“The proposed witnesses are attorneys who have generally engaged in communications that are protected by several governmental privileges,” Woodward said. “They have each been instructed to assert all of those privileges at the scheduled hearing and in any further proceedings in this matter.” 

“To nonetheless force these attorneys onto the stand and judicially cross-examine them would pose an intolerably high risk of violating those privileges,” Woodward argued.  

That would leave only Todd Blanche and Donald Trump to provide answers.  

“If the court believes that adequate evidence is lacking without the necessarily privileged information it plans to tease out, the correct approach would be to cease the inquiry and leave the matter ‘for the Attorney General and the President to evaluate’” Woodward said in his filing. 

Woodward told the court that if it believed it necessary that Hogan, Skiba and Almendarez testify, the court should “defer the scheduled (Dec. 2) hearing to a later date to allow the United States to seek reconsideration or, if necessary, appellate review.” 

According to the court’s ruling posted online Monday, Perry denied the government’s motion and told the parties to confer on the issues. If agreement cannot be reached “regarding the scope of applicable privileges,” the judge ruled, the parties are to submit “the relevant portion of the proffered testimony and why any potential privilege should not apply” for the judge to consider privately in her chambers before making a ruling. 

Woodward has until Nov. 25 to file his response with Perry “as to why a privilege should apply.” 

Join the discussion on social media!