Thank you, Ken Trainor, for “Unchecked, unbalanced, un-supreme” [Viewpoints, June 18]. Your well-researched overview of the history of the Supreme Court and the shifts you describe toward the court becoming more governed by ideology and partisanship are thought-provoking for me.
If I understand it correctly, this third branch of our government was designed to be above politics, a group of erudite jurists with deep knowledge of the Constitution and the law, the least corruptible branch. Now we see that it has become dominated by the conservative majority with mostly 5-4 or 6-3 decisions, depending on whether Justice Barrett joins the other three women to rule on the liberal side.
I think back to 2000 when Al Gore conceded the election to George W. Bush despite winning the popular vote by more than half a million votes. Not only did Gore have years of experience in the Senate and House of Representatives, plus eight years as vice president, but he had dedicated himself to a study of the environment and had knowledge of climate change, which the country so needs. Instead, Bush’s presidency, which I think of as the Cheney-Rumsfeld presidency, gave us the misguided and enormously costly war in Iraq. The election came down to that one-vote majority by the Supreme Court, stopping the recount of votes in Florida. What a difference that one vote made.
Even more grievous was the 2016 election that put Donald Trump in the White House despite the fact that Secretary of State Hillary Clinton won the popular vote by three million votes. This time it was the Electoral College that made the decision. The difference between what might have been with Clinton’s leadership and the reality of what has been with Trump’s administration is impossible to calculate.
It has changed the nature of our country by ripping apart government institutions built over decades to serve our needs and regulate our economic system. As dedicated civil servants are casually dismissed, our government is drained of institutional knowledge and human capital.
The campaign to deport immigrants strikes me as the epitome of injustice. We are living now with fear and fragmentation, a contest between democracy and autocracy.
Most troubling to me is the marriage of wealth and power, and concentration of both in the hands of a small number of people, predominantly men, who are empowered to make decisions that impact the lives of millions of others. This is not a new thing in human history. The scale of it must be greater than ever now, if only because of the scale of the human population.
Nothing is more important than finding mature, knowledgeable, empathic, responsible leadership to head our government and communities.
Stephanie Ferrera
Oak Park
