Physical education teacher Chris Ledbetter and Oak Park and River Forest High School District 200 have apparently reached a settlement in an employment discrimination case lawsuit filed by Ledbetter in Cook County Circuit Court in December 2019 and removed to U.S. District Court in February.

Judge Joan A. Lefkow noted in the court record that the parties had agreed to a settlement at a June 10 hearing. Details of the settlement were not made available.

In addition to the high school, Athletic Director John Stelzer, and the school’s former principal, Nathan Rouse, were named as defendants in the lawsuit.

School board members were expected to approve the settlement agreement at their June 25 meeting, but the action item was moved to the next regular meeting.

Ledbetter’s attorney, Thomas C. Cronin, did not return Wednesday Journal’s inquiries on this matter. District 200 board President Sarah Dixon Spivey and Karin Sullivan, OPRF’s executive director of Communications and Community Relations, said the district can’t issue a comment until the board approves the settlement.

Ledbetter had been seeking in excess of $50,000 from the district after he claimed the school violated his rights under the Americans with Disabilities Act. Ledbetter is a recovering addict and, according to a March 11 court filing by the defendants answering Ledbetter’s complaint. According to the complaint, Ledbetter believed that was the reason he was removed as OPRF’s varsity baseball head coach after 17 years.

In the complaint, Ledbetter claimed he had been sober since 2017 after completing a treatment program to assist him with his dependency issues. During that time, OPRF appointed an interim baseball head coach while he took a leave of absence.

According to court documents, after a month back at the school and leading summer workouts, OPRF “prepared and offered a renewed contract for Ledbetter to serve as Head Varsity Boys Baseball Coach for the 2017-18 season” in late July of 2017. 

The school denied in the complaint that a contract existed.

Ledbetter also alleged his rights were violated when Rouse and Stelzer “required” him to apologize to the athletic department, his colleagues, coaches and assistants.

As a result, he claimed to have “suffered substantial damages as the result of [Rouse and Stelzer’s] unlawful actions, including the loss of his job as Head Varsity [coach] and the loss of other ancillary jobs, damage to his reputation, substantial economic loss, severe emotional distress, and other physical and mental injuries.”

In its answer to the complaint, the defendants also denied that this happened.

Ledbetter stated later in his complaint that, after he had taken three days off for the flu, OPRF started asking about his movements during the school day and that his colleagues were asked if he had engaged in illegal drug use.

When he returned to the school the following week, Ledbetter was put on administrative leave. He alleged that Rouse and Stelzer “required him to take an immediate drug test.” Ledbetter claimed to have passed the drug test he took the day after his three-day absence but was told to resign before the results were in.

OPRF denied all of these claims.

Ledbetter was brought back as a physical education teacher but was not reinstated as OPRF’s baseball head coach. Joseph Parenti’s interim tag was removed, and he has been the head coach of the program since Ledbetter was removed from the position.

On the same day, March 11, that the defendants filed their answer to Ledbetter’s complaint, Stelzer and Rouse also filed a motion to dismiss the case for failure to state a claim.

They argued, as individual defendants, that the ADA “does not allow for liability against individuals who are not ’employers’ as defined by the act.”

They go on to argue that “employers” are defined by the ADA as “a person engaged in an industry affecting commerce who has 15 or more employees … and any ‘agent’ of such person,” which, they argue, would clear them of Ledbetter’s claims that they violated the ADA.

Two days later, President Trump declared a national state of emergency due to the global outbreak of COVID-19 which put this matter on hold.

At the June 10 hearing, Lefkow apparently was slated to render a decision on the motion to dismiss. With news of the settlement, that issue became moot.


RELATED: Q&A w/OPRF’s new boys basketball head coach

RELATED: IHSA approves girls wrestling state series for 2021-22 

RELATED: Fenwick football cancels Ireland trip

Join the discussion on social media!

24 replies on “District 200, former baseball coach reportedly settle lawsuit”