Bad journalism, cheap

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

By Dan Haley

Editor and Publisher

Nobody cares about Journatic, a colleague said to me Monday. Then he allowed that maybe 200 people in all of Chicago, mainly local news folks, cared about Journatic. I say you add in the devoted Tribune haters and very quickly you're over a thousand people who care about Journatic.

What, you ask, is Journatic? It is the latest embarrassment for the Trib which just recently turned over the keys to its TribLocal gambit — both online and in print — to a company founded by River Forester Brian Timpone. Even worse, when it made its TribLocal deal with Journatic, the Trib bought a chunk of the company.

Timpone's conceit was that he could do local news better and cheaper than the old-line media with its "broken model" of locally-based reporters who actually went out and reported news. Well, it turns out that Timpone was right about the cheaper part. He focused on data-driven reporting. That's a method of scouring public data — police reports, property transfers, high school basketball results, LinkedIn pages, whatever — and then finding some inexpensive way to put a few words around the factoids.

This results in coverage such as last week's page one bombshell in the local version of TribLocal that Oak Park and River Forest had, between them, about 100 practicing dentists. Stretched across two inside pages, this remarkable report was produced, the story told us, by "the TribLocal Research Team."

Who might this crack team be? There were some reporters and copy editors on this continent. There were fancy software programs that could spin out some sports clichés to wrap around a box score. But as NPR's "This American Life" reported 10 days ago, mainly there were people in the Philippines being paid 35 cents a story to gin up a few paragraphs for a local story for the Tribune, the Houston Chronicle, and a lot of other notable newspapers.

Since the radio report scalded Journatic, more actual reporting has taken place and, not surprisingly, the other key to the efficiency of the high volume, half-buck per story model was to violate every rule of journalism. So we've got faked bylines (Hello, Amy Anderson), plagiarism and the always frowned-on journalism practice of just making stuff up.

This has led the Trib to dump Journatic "indefinitely" and to promise that, going forward, TribLocal would be written by Trib reporters and "trusted freelancers." Old school, but hey, it just might work.

I know this sounds like gloating, but I don't mean to. We are in a moment of "disruptive chaos" in the news business, as the smart folks like to call it. The old model isn't going to get us through, and certainly here at Wednesday Journal we have many challenges. The future is uncertain and change — digital first news reporting, pushing content through social media and e-mail, engaging readers on social media, more video, unique print content, reader-submitted pictures and content, live comment boards, and, yes, data-based reporting — well the change can't come fast enough.

But there is something at the core of what we do that is unchanging. And that's what Journatic's model can't imagine. It is what a once-great company like the Chicago Tribune lost track of in trying to pump up the volume and squeeze the unit cost of its community coverage.

A good local story is about connection. Connections exist between people. Connections come with a sense of place. Connections come with context. It's great that there are 100 dentists in Oak Park and River Forest. But tell me one great story about one dentist who has done something extraordinary. That's community journalism.

Email: Twitter: @OPEditor

Reader Comments

5 Comments - Add Your Comment

Note: This page requires you to login with Facebook to comment.

Comment Policy

Hey now! from OP  

Posted: July 18th, 2012 9:56 PM

Not much difference between what Journatic does and what the WJ does when it seemingly merely re-types press releases, etc. provided to them by the various gov't entities into stories....of course things seem to get a little more interesting when the Editor has a self-interest; i.e. Oak Park Ave. & South Blvd. biz district retail overlay...


Posted: July 18th, 2012 8:19 PM

Your lead story online is about Dean Nichols. You could have had a reporter walk down to his home at 304 S. Oak Park Ave in less then 2 minutes and do some actual reporting. Instead, we get a couple of photos of new concrete being poured in front of Maya Del Sol, which is directly across the street from the Wednesday Journal. Talk about lazy journalism.

John Butch Murtagh from Oak Park, Illinois  

Posted: July 18th, 2012 8:13 PM

I agree with Dan's view that "connections" are the key to a good or great local story. What I am hesitant about is the slam on the concept of multi media electronics to search for facts. In the old newspaper days, stringers were used to find stories around town using their connections to the street. Great sources were bellman, taxi drivers, bartenders, etc. The stringer got the write the story on occasions, but most of the time it was a matter of slipping him a few bucks for the scoop. The Barwin story was a scoop. The likelihood that he would take a job in Florida appeared in the Oak Leaves and WJ Comments before it was covered in the WJ Print Edition. When covered, the WJ Print Edition did not mention Florida Sunshine Laws which revealed that many people in the community were aware of the conflicts with the board that led to his departure. It could be a story worth a "skip", but the WJ did a critical editorial about the board silence on Bawin's resignation. It was a subject you embraced and then buried. I think while WJ is an outstanding paper, it is weak on investigated reporting. The Barwin revelation is an example. In 2012, newspapers have little choice but to make multi media electronics search capabilities to enhance their connections. Filling the stringers' role electronically is critical to fight off external competition.

Q from Oak Park  

Posted: July 18th, 2012 7:03 PM

Mr. Haley, a great local story would be why Barwin left. What is going on with the Sertus owned, once owed by tax payers land. There are certainly a lot of great local stories that people would grab a copy of the W.J., to read about, but until then, local folks like Enuf is Enuf, John Butch Murtagh, will continue to dig out facts. It saves the W.J. time and money, and that may be why social media is taking over the newspaper business. Social Media knows what people want to know.

Scott Watson from St Louis, MO  

Posted: July 18th, 2012 5:47 PM

Thank you fornthe clarity around Journatic. When I heard the TAL story, I figured this would further deteriorate a profession that needs to be rethought, but not removed. Connections are the key. Things like sources, local knowledge, etc.,tell the story...which is what journalism should be.

Facebook Connect

Answer Book 2019

To view the full print edition of the Wednesday Journal 2019 Answer Book, please click here.

Quick Links

Sign-up to get the latest news updates for Oak Park and River Forest.

MultimediaContact us
Submit Letter To The Editor
Place a Classified Ad

Classified Ad