The VMA is dead. Long live ...?

Opinion: Columns

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

By Robert Milstein

One View

When someone dies, we all say positive things and try to make the pain easier to bear. The VMA is dead. Remember the good times, the successes, the victories, the laughter, and the people. But the VMA is an institution, not a person ... it was a political machine that moved from high ideals to let's win elections so "we" can be in charge. 

The VMA served the village well for many decades. The founders had a purpose. They wanted to use the great thinkers approach to governing. They read Aristotle, Plato and many other Great Books. They came up with the VMA, an innovative, thoughtful organization for good government. Where did I learn this? I learned from the source, the VMA stalwarts: Doug Wyman, Bob Kane, Barbara Furlong, Gene and Ann Armstrong, Cy Giddings and others. They taught everyone about the philosophy of the VMA. They are, and were, true believers in the VMA. 

But being true believers can be your downfall. 

Along the way, reform-minded VMA members sought changes in the group, and they were permitted by the leadership to take a shot at new ideas. The group never got the support it needed. This is history and I am certain others read this effort differently. 

With any reform of the VMA a non-starter, the VMA lost members, who then ran against their slates. The VCA took one seat. Then the NLP took three seats. The VMA fought back to win their power. Along comes Anan Abu-Taleb, striking another blow, even though he is a VMA guy at heart. Finally, in the last election independents swept the VMA candidates out of office. 

One might say, in an earlier election, David Pope also beat the VMA, but he was the real VMA candidate, not Trustee Diane Carpenter. Besides, he rejoined the fold of the VMA after his election as village president. 

The VMA was running on vapors in the last election. Kevin Peppard and I brought challenges to the VMA petitions because they did not follow the law. The courts saw it differently. The village rigged their findings on this, according to the VMA-elected village clerk. So the citizens put the VMA away with a knockout by independents.

The VMA became less relevant after the last election. 

We now have VOICE, a new group. They sound good from the media coverage. Among the people who are not involved in any group, we are listening. Lay out your progressive plans for Oak Park. Provide your blueprint for the future. 

Suggestion: look at the VMA Facebook site and scroll down the pages. There are citizens of all types holding signs about why they love Oak Park: the parks, always something to do, churches, schools, and many more, but not one sign says I love Oak Park for its high-rises, unbridled economic development, high taxes, failed alleys, lack of parking, traffic jams, failed intersections, etc. 

We are waiting to see the future and we are looking to independents and to VOICE —you are now the de facto leaders that people are watching. What do you have to offer? 

Please be specific.

Robert Milstein is a former Oak Park village trustee.

Reader Comments

1 Comment - Add Your Comment

Note: This page requires you to login with Facebook to comment.

Comment Policy

Kevin Peppard from Oak Park  

Posted: June 20th, 2018 5:48 PM

For the record, Bob, when you and I each independently challenged the VMA's nominating petitions (only later did we join forces), the Illinois Appellate Court actually did find that the nomination papers violated the law. But there were to be no consequences, since the law was "directory", not "mandatory." In any case, our effort probably had little effect on the election. The VMA collapsed on its own. Our court case did not establish a precedent, one way or the other, because of how the decision was handed down. It's all a moot point for the future, since another case (at the level of the Federal 7th Circuit Court of Appeals) threw out key requirements for running as a political party in Illinois anyway. They actually could have run as a party, even though they didn't have a full slate.

Facebook Connect

Answer Book 2018

To view the full print edition of the Wednesday Journal 2018 Answer Book, please click here.

Quick Links

Sign-up to get the latest news updates for Oak Park and River Forest.

MultimediaContact us
Submit Letter To The Editor
Place a Classified Ad

Classified Ad