What rights?

Opinion: Columns

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

By Michael Romain

Staff Reporter

Devon Horton, the superintendent of Evanston/Skokie School District 65, is a witness to how difficult it is to achieve equity during a pandemic. 

Horton, who is Black, decided that "Evanston schools would give students from marginalized groups first priority for seats for in-person learning and all other students would be taught remotely," according to a Wall Street Journal article published Oct. 6. 

During a Zoom meeting, the Journal reported, Horton said the decision was "about equity for Black and brown students, for special education students, for our LGBTQ students." 

His stance earned him scorn, death threats "from both residents and nonresidents of Evanston" — a college town, "home to many professors who work at Northwestern University, which hugs the shorelines of Lake Michigan," where four years ago, "voters supported Hillary Clinton over Donald Trump by more than 10 to 1. Last year, the city created a first-in-the-nation reparations fund for Black residents." 

For its part, the District 65 school board wrote an open letter to the liberal Evanston community. 

"When you challenge policies and protocols established to ensure an equitable experience for Black and brown students, you are part of a continuum of resistance to equity and desire to maintain white supremacy," the board wrote, according to the Journal's reporting. 

That position, unsurprisingly, startled parents like Corinna Raimondo, a scientist from Italy and an adjunct professor at Northwestern. The Journal reported that Raimondo had started a petition urging the board to let all children return to school. 

"I'm being told to just shut up," Raimondo said, referencing the board's response. "I don't think that is right. Everybody should have the right to express an opinion." 

I've seen some version of Raimondo's response quite a bit during this pandemic. I think these statements are harmful, but not because they're critical of a school administrator's ostensible attempt to 'do equity.' It's how these kinds of critiques are framed that's problematic. 

Raimondo is essentially pitting her personal freedom versus equality; her negative rights (i.e., her right to free speech) against the district's good-faith effort to address the fact that, as an institution, it has aided and abetted the moral crime of withholding from Black and brown people the positive right to an education.  

The question I'd pose to Raimondo is if you feel that rights are so important to you, imagine those rights being taken away? In other words, imagine what it's like to be Black. Black people have to live within a nexus of un-freedom all the time. It is our birthright. 

We almost take it for granted that we don't have the same rights as whites and we expect whites to go crazy when we so much as petition the government for a redress of grievances; that's because America has conditioned white people for centuries to believe that their rights exist in inverse relation to the enforcement of rights for Blacks. 

In the Reactionary Mind: Conservatism from Edmund Burke to Sarah Palin, the historian Corey Robin traces this dynamic to its original form. 

When former vice president and pro-slavery political theorist John Calhoun declared that the destruction of the evil institution would mean the destruction of "us as a people," he was thinking of "individual men absorbed in the day-to-day experience of ruling other men and women," Robin writes. "Take that experience away, and you destroyed not only the master but also the man — and the many men who sought to become, or thought they already were like, the master." 

That's how the system of white supremacy operates to this day, centuries after slavery's end. So much of our language of personal rights and personal freedom is simply a mask for Calhoun's way of thinking (the pandemic pun is intended).  

 Unfortunately, too many people — white and Black — let themselves become bit players in this heinous system by pitting the cult of personal freedom (i.e., the freedom to go for what's good for me and mine) against the common good. And the common good is only as robust as its most vulnerable parts, which include marginalized students in Evanston and Oak Park. 

Now, more than ever, we all need to align ourselves with the needs and interests of the most vulnerable people in our society — racial minorities, the handicapped, the poor, the sick — because their particular present is always and forever our collective future. 

I applaud what Horton is doing in principle, even though I'm not familiar with how that will work out in practice. And I think there may be valid criticisms of the plan and its execution. Please, have the debate.  

But we have to stop talking as if, by attempting to do justice on behalf of a historically and systemically excluded minority or by prioritizing the common good, an institution is trampling on our personal rights. That kind of narrative glosses over other people's suffering, invites white revanchism, plays into the conservative misappropriation of "freedom" and makes it impossible to reach healthy consensus. 

CONTACT: michael@oakpark.com  

Love the Journal?

Become our partner in independent community journalism

Thanks for turning to Wednesday Journal and OakPark.com. We love our thousands of digital-only readers. Now though we're asking you to partner up in paying for our reporters and photographers who report this news. It had to happen, right?

On the plus side, we're giving you a simple way, and a better reason, to join in. We're now a non-profit -- Growing Community Media -- so your donation is tax deductible. And signing up for a monthly donation, or making a one-time donation, is fast and easy.

No threats from us. The news will be here. No paywalls or article countdowns. We're counting on an exquisite mix of civic enlightenment and mild shaming. Sort of like public radio.

Claim your bragging rights. Become a digital member.

Donate Now

Reader Comments

6 Comments - Add Your Comment

Note: This page requires you to login with Facebook to comment.

Comment Policy

Michael O'Malley  

Posted: October 27th, 2020 8:50 PM

It might, on the face of it, seem reactionary to reactionary minds but Mr. Romaine's "arguments" aren't remotely plausible. When you twist the sincere concerns of a mother looking after the welfare of her children, and burden her with the sins of the despicable racist history of this country you've lost me and I suspect many of the readers of this paper. The author can reference all the historians and philosophers he likes, but this piece is simple bullying. The author and the WJ should be ashamed.

Tom MacMillan from Oak Park  

Posted: October 27th, 2020 2:12 PM

And WJ is covering John Calhoun, who was VP in the 1820's, because it has only been a couple centuries. Evanston should just be more like Oak Park, and realize the way to equity is a giant new swimming pool for the rich kids to hold regionals within.

William Dwyer Jr.  

Posted: October 27th, 2020 12:11 PM

So, the Wednesday Journal is covering Evanston now?

Tom MacMillan from Oak Park  

Posted: October 27th, 2020 11:05 AM

Brian - I think Dr. Horton really mishandled this. All he had to do is say that Special Education was the first priority. Instead he made it about skin color, not about need. That guy has a mission impossible job, as you don't just change a school schedule and suddenly years of private violin lessons, high speed internet access and parents with masters degrees stop excelling. Meanwhile, portraying a mother with three small kids as being bad for trying to get them everything she can is not very productive.

Brian Slowiak  

Posted: October 27th, 2020 10:49 AM

Why aren't all the under performing students in this system being given access to priority seating?

Tom MacMillan from Oak Park  

Posted: October 27th, 2020 10:11 AM

In Evanston, Raimondo pays reparations, for what her family did not do in the USA, because they were in Italy. And she gets heat for daring to even talk about her three kids and their school? Yeah, she is the bad guy in this story, if we are having that debate.

Facebook Connect

Answer Book 2019

To view the full print edition of the Wednesday Journal 2019 Answer Book, please click here.

Quick Links

Sign-up to get the latest news updates for Oak Park and River Forest.

MultimediaContact us
Submit Letter To The Editor
Place a Classified Ad

Classified Ad