Reasonable tax debate

Opinion: Editorials

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

By Editorial

Our Views

It was a good start last week as a group of Oak Park residents, previously assembled only in a Facebook group, came to life in a meet-up at the main library. The topic: concern over the impact of Oak Park's ever-rising property tax bills. 

Some 50 people gathered to both put a face to a name and to talk about priorities of the group going forward.

 Among the ideas forwarded out of small group sessions were consolidating government bodies with a focus on combining the township and village governments. Evanston accomplished that goal in recent years while River Forest village government's attempt at a hostile takeover of its township turned into a nasty and failed effort. Merging township and municipal governments is a position the Journal has supported in both Oak Park and River Forest over decades. 

We'd also resurrect our support for a serious effort to merge fire departments in both villages as a way to save on staffing and equipment and building maintenance. It's an idea that gets lip service from public officials but has yet to rise to the level of serious debate. A strong group pushing for tax savings could change that.

A segment of those at last week's meeting said Oak Park needed a change in culture around taxation. We agree. Too often taxing bodies have actively proclaimed their fiduciary duty to tax at maximum rates with the explanation that they were elected solely to represent the interests of their distinct taxing body. That is the sort of silo thinking that has gotten us into this predicament and leaves a body such as the Council of Governments, an informal group representing leaders of all local taxing bodies, debating the joint purchase of office supplies when their vista should be much wider.

There are tests just ahead for each of our taxing bodies. The school districts are presently negotiating new teacher contracts. Will raises be at the rate of inflation or will the school boards fall back on the circular logic that they must compare all teacher raises to what "comparable" districts are paying faculty? That indefensible rationale has resulted in a lot of pay hikes far in excess of the private sector over decades.

And support them or not, four new downtown Oak Park high-rises are either built or underway. They will generate substantial new property taxes and, in truth, not a great deal of added costs to schools, public works or fire. The Oak Park Property Tax Watch Group should seek pledges now from each taxing body that they use that new revenue to offset property taxes currently paid by homeowners and commercial property owners.

Finally, we were glad to hear some participants in this meeting laud Oak Park's progressive values and historic diversity. Taxing wisely is not automatically in opposition to investing in social programs that foster our shared progressive values.

Reader Comments

2 Comments - Add Your Comment

Note: This page requires you to login with Facebook to comment.

Comment Policy

Brian Lantz  

Posted: January 17th, 2018 4:52 PM

I agree with Neal. This is a good summary of the issues raised at the meeting. A lot of ideas exchanged, including collapsing the Park District and Townships into the Village as Evanston did to get control of spending. It was, however, saddening to hear from such a high percentage of the older residents that they are facing being priced out of their homes (in some case multi-generational residents) due to poor tax decisions by the districts. Hopefully, the officials that were present were listening carefully.

Neal Buer from Oak Park  

Posted: January 17th, 2018 4:10 PM

Excellent opinion piece. I hope everyone reads this a couple of times because it is filled with good ideas. As part of the tax group, I am looking for constructive ways to reduce the tax increases to the cost of living increases. It is not a radical idea. If it is, I'm going to call social security, because they limit my increases to the cost of living.

Facebook Connect

Answer Book 2018

To view the full print edition of the Wednesday Journal 2018 Answer Book, please click here.

Quick Links

Sign-up to get the latest news updates for Oak Park and River Forest.

MultimediaContact us
Submit Letter To The Editor
Place a Classified Ad

Classified Ad