I must admit that I haven’t been to, nor plan to attend any of the Oak Park Plan Commission’s hearings on the proposal to convert the abandoned Comcast Building to low-income housing. I go to bed around 8PM so evening meetings don’t work for me. In addition, I don’t live in the neighborhood, and I don’t feel that strongly one way or another about low-income housing. But I am interested in how people, and in particular the enlightened citizens of Oak Park, resolve their differences when there are strong feelings on both sides of an issue.

Now I get it that democracy requires an opportunity for all sides to blow of steam in the hopes that their voice will be heard. So the Plan Commission holds a bunch of meetings and everybody’s blood pressure spikes for a couple of hours. Partisans are seldom very objective, and their evidence is often slanted and biased.

I previously noted that  I don’t have a dog in this fight so my heart and mind are pure. With that in mind, may I suggest that the Plan Commision gather this information if not for itself then for everyone that would like to be a little more informed on the issue.                        

First, get a commercial real estate man like Anthony Shaker or David King to advise what’s the likely future for this property if it isn’t converted to low-income housing? Will it sit empty for 10 years? What other buyers might find it attractive? Hooters? Sorry. Just kidding.                   

Then let’s get the Township Assessor Ali ElSaffar over and tell about projected real estate values and taxes and all the other stuff assessor’s talk about. And then maybe the directors of a couple of low-income projects in the Chicago area who can tell us about their experiences on eligibility, stability, crime, whatever. A sight visit could perhaps be arranged.                  

Finally, I’m sure we could get some professor from one of the many universities in the third largest city in America who’s an expert on the subject to opine.  He could tells us what he has learned after spending his whole lifetime studying the subject.                                        

The more independent information and expert opinion we get the better. I suspect the Commission is probably doing this anyway, but I just wanted to be sure.                       

One final thing. Yesterday I was surprised that Regis Philbin retired. I thought he was dead.

Join the discussion on social media!

John Hubbuch

John is an Indiana native who moved to Oak Park in 1976. He served on the District 97 school board, coached youth sports and, more recently, retired from the law. That left him time to become a Wednesday...

6 replies on “Less Heat More Light On Comcast Building Hearings”