Are D97 teacher recommendations open to parents?

Elementary district says no. OPRF opens file. Parent sues D97

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

By Terry Dean

Staff reporter

When Kim Werner requested a copy of a teacher recommendation for her child that was sent from her middle school to Oak Park and River Forest High School when her son started his freshmen year this fall, she was turned down by District 97.

She then requested the information from the high school and received it. Werner later filed a lawsuit against the Oak Park elementary school district, claiming that the district violated state law regarding who has access to a student's records.

The complaint was filed in June. District 97 declined to comment on the suit. "It is the district's policy not to comment on any litigation," said Chris Jasculca, the district's communications coordinator via an email. Werner declined to speak to the Journal about the suit and directed the paper to contact her attorney.

The 15-page complaint contends that Dist. 97 for some time has had a "de facto policy" of allowing middle school teachers to provide student educational information and course recommendations to OPRF teachers and department heads concerning placement in high school courses.

Erik Newton, a Chicago attorney with the firm Lumen Law is representing Werner. He said parents should be allowed to see any written recommendations about their child that are provided by their teachers. According to Newton, Dist. 97 told Werner that it did not consider the written recommendations "student records."

Newton disagreed, citing the Illinois Student Records Act which defines student records as "any writing or other recorded information concerning a student and by which a student may be individually identified..."

The suit also contends that parents are not notified when the recommendations are being sent to the high school. Newton added that parents should receive prior notice and be allowed to inspect or perhaps even question what was written about their child. He stressed that school districts should share information and collaborate about students but should do so by following the law.

"Her son's rights were violated under the statute," he said concerning Werner's child.

Along with compensation for legal fees incurred by Werner, Newton said his client is also looking for Dist. 97 to follow the law.

"We'd like to see them try and correct this for other kids and their families," he said.

Wednesday Journal contacted the Illinois State Board of Education to speak with an official concerning student records law but did not get a return call by press time.

Reader Comments

1 Comment - Add Your Comment

Note: This page requires you to login with Facebook to comment.

Comment Policy

john murtagh from Oak Park  

Posted: November 2nd, 2010 7:37 PM

In my early twenties, an Irish Christian Brother came to my sister%u2019s wake. My uncle asked the brother what kind of student I had been. The Brother said quote Absolutely Horrid unquote. Shortly after the wake, I applied for a job in the mailroom at a major corporation. My interviews went poorly but I got the job. In my forties, I examined my personnel files at the company. I found a derogatory note attached to my high school transcript saying I was lazy, a poor student, and unlikely to succeed upon graduation. Written notes last ages in peoples files. The Werners were correct in suing D97.

Facebook Connect

Answer Book 2017

To view the full print edition of the Wednesday Journal 2017 Answer Book, please click here.

Quick Links

Sign-up to get the latest news updates for Oak Park and River Forest.

MultimediaContact us
Submit Letter To The Editor
Place a Classified Ad