Girl Scout Cookies. I Wish I Liked Them.

I buy them, but they're not that good

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

By David Hammond

I was a Boy Scout, my dad was Scout Master, my wife was a Brownie leader. I support the Girl Scouts in sprit and with my dollars every spring, when we buy Girl Scout cookies from neighbors, my wife's students,  just about everyone who asks.

Thing is, they're not good cookies. Hate to say it; it even hurts a little to say it, but these cookies are just a slight cut above what you might find on a commodity grocery aisle – edible, sure, but not satisfying in terms of taste, texture, anything.

A few years ago, I wrote on this blog that these cookies "are fine, but not great."  Now I'm thinking that "fine" is an exaggerated descriptor of these solidly mediocre cookies.

Cookies are my favorite dessert/snack. I think about them frequently and write about them now and again.

 I am not, however, a snob about cookies. They don't have to be made with fancy-pants ingredients, rare chocolate, bacon, whatever. I just like a good cookie and, alas, Girl Scout cookies are not that good.

And this is the time of year for Girl Scout cookies, so I feel I must speak out.

To take the two most pathetic examples of the cookie maker's art, as practiced for the Girl Scouts:

* Caramel DeLites (formerly called Samoas) have thick, cheap chocolate and cocoanut flavor that always makes me feel dirty for eating them. I like caramel a lot, but the ingredients list doesn't include caramel, though it does include corn syrup, sweetened condensed milk, sorbitol, and dextrose. One cookie is 70 calories, and about half of that is fat, with loads of sugar (which I'd accept in a better cookie – but in this format, sugar is simply not worth the calories).  I used to eat these cookies and thought they were okay; now, they taste bad, and I don't know if it's the cookie or me or both. Probably both: many of us become more discriminating as we age, and as products age, and companies feel pressure to show greater profit, something's got to give, and that something is usually quality.

* Peanut Butter Patties (formerly Tagalongs). One bite, and all I taste is waxy chocolate and peanut butter that feels on the tongue like it was cut with lard. But tastes may be deceiving: the label says there's actually less than 2% chocolate in these cookies, so maybe what I taste is not actually chocolate at all. Whatever it is, it isn't good. There's a perceptible decrease in peanut butter flavor in Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, too; I'm guessing a lot of snacks that use peanut butter are cutting this venerable product with shortening or some other less expensive additive.

Thin mints…well, just as with a cheap wine, if you chill these cookies, you can consume them without triggering a gag response.

I don't feel good about saying any of this. Criticizing Girl Scout cookies is not a winning proposition. They're beloved, like so much bad food, probably for nostalgic reasons rather than for the quality of the cookie.  Nostalgia is, I've found, the only marginally acceptable defense for eating such egregiously horrid concoctions as these cookies, White Castle hamburgers, and Kraft Mac n' Cheese.

Still, as I mentioned, I support the Girl Scouts; I think they're a fine organization, just poorly represented by these substandard snacks.  This year, when I'm approached by a passel of little girls selling the cookies in front of the library, I'll order no cookies, but instead write a check in support of the Girl Scouts. I'll then gently encourage the young ladies to demand a better product from their distributors…a product that I, currently, am not going to eat. If, as the literature suggests, girls learn about business from selling these cookies, then this will help them learn how to accept sincere feedback from sympathetic customers.

Reader Comments

12 Comments - Add Your Comment

Note: This page requires you to login with Facebook to comment.

Comment Policy

Troop Leader from Oak Park, Illinois  

Posted: February 20th, 2014 11:03 PM

Not true at all. Most troops (except the really young girls) do an outdoor camp out at least once a year.

Troop Beverly Hills  

Posted: February 19th, 2014 2:10 PM

Is it true Girl Scouts rarely go camping, and when they do, its indoors?

Troop Leader  

Posted: February 19th, 2014 1:19 PM

If you want to support the Girl Scouts organization but don't want the cookies, you can have them shipped to military units stationed overseas. You just give the Scouts the money, then GSUSA sends the boxes to the USO. A fine way to support two great organizations!

GS Mom  

Posted: February 19th, 2014 12:52 PM

Where are you getting your cookies? Oak Park girl scouts are selling Samoas, Tagalongs, etc., as always. The other varieties are made by a different manufacturer and distributed in other regions.

OP Transplant  

Posted: February 19th, 2014 11:52 AM

Guys, it's okay not to like the cookies, and it's okay not to buy them. It's a little over the top to take the time and energy to blog about how much you don't like them. What grown man makes it his business to discourage people from participating in a GSA fundraiser?

Phil from Oak Park  

Posted: February 19th, 2014 7:25 AM

Spot on, David. I, too, once recall somewhat enjoying these cookies. (Same with the Reeses.) Don't know what happened, but they're now terrible. (Perhaps why they changed the names when they were "reformulated"?)


Posted: February 18th, 2014 8:29 PM

All I buy are the shortbreads (good with tea) and the thin mints. I have to disagree with Mr. Hammond on the latter; I really like them.

Another Grumpy Blogger  

Posted: February 18th, 2014 5:36 PM

I agree! Also, why won't those darn kids stay off my lawn? And what's with the haircuts? You can't tell the girls from the boys. Why, in my day...

John Butch Murtagh from Oak Park, Illinois  

Posted: February 18th, 2014 4:08 PM

David, pretty sure there is a spot for you at Fox News. The Scrooge resigned.

Yvonne O'Connor from Chicago, Illinois  

Posted: February 18th, 2014 3:43 PM

Totally agree. We buy them because its hard to turn down a kid, but they sit in the kitchen unopened and eventually get taken to work for the masses...

David Hammond from Oak Park, Illinois  

Posted: February 15th, 2014 4:08 PM

We're making home-made Samoas. That's how I'm getting "ready."  

Posted: February 13th, 2014 6:43 PM

And the cookies for Oak Park area GS's get delivered this Saturday so get ready... That being said, other GS councils get different cookies and I've been jealous the last few years of the councils that have a breakfast bar option...

Facebook Connect

Answer Book 2017

To view the full print edition of the Wednesday Journal 2017 Answer Book, please click here.

Quick Links

Sign-up to get the latest news updates for Oak Park and River Forest.

MultimediaContact us
Submit Letter To The Editor
Place a Classified Ad